3.6 KiB
3.6 KiB
Verdict: automaton
Status: PASS
Completion Date: 2026-06-11
Summary
automaton has a score of 78 from the Bug Finder and 65 from the Adversarial Bug Finder, for a combined score of 143. All 30 bugs have been fixed. The framework is well-designed at a high level and the critical issues in the Orchestrator — the state machine logic, auto-execution loop, and sub-task management — have been resolved.
Findings
What Passed
- The overall framework architecture is sound — the state machine, phase separation, and artifact-based progression are well-designed
- The interactive protocol for Research and Design phases is robust
- The VRAM configuration and detection system is comprehensive
- The bug finder and adversarial bug finder prompts are thorough and well-structured
- The doc review phase fills a genuine gap in the workflow
- All 30 bugs have been fixed
What Failed
- None — all bugs have been fixed
What Needs Review
- None — all bugs have been fixed
Tasks for Review / Tie-Breaks
None.
Remaining Issues
None.
Score
| Bug | Severity | Score | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Critical | +10 | FIXED — State determination reordered |
| 2 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Duplicate paragraph removed |
| 3 | High | +5 | FIXED — Empty IMPLEMENTATION.md creation removed |
| 4 | High | +5 | FIXED — VERDICT.md check added |
| 5 | High | +5 | FIXED — Orphaned sub-tasks check added |
| 6 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Wave enforcement added |
| 7 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Sub-task prioritization added |
| 8 | High | +5 | FIXED — Artifact validation added |
| 9 | Low | +1 | FIXED — Units clarified in VRAM_CONFIG.md |
| 10 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Sub-task scope added to PARENT_SPEC.md |
| 11 | High | +5 | FIXED — Sub-task fix task creation added |
| 12 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Script existence check added |
| 13 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Script failure handling added |
| 14 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Sub-task verdict aggregation added |
| 15 | Low | +1 | FIXED — Sub-task tie-break task creation added |
| 16 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Empty artifact checks added |
| 17 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Sub-task wave prioritization added |
| 18 | Low | +1 | FIXED — Auto-Execution Rules consolidated |
| Adv1 | Critical | +10 | FIXED — Auto-execution loop timeout/iteration limit added |
| Adv2 | High | +5 | FIXED — Duplicate sub-task prevention added |
| Adv3 | High | +5 | FIXED — VRAM detection caching added |
| Adv4 | High | +5 | FIXED — Orphaned sub-tasks check added |
| Adv5 | High | +5 | FIXED — Sub-task parallel execution added |
| Adv6 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Overlapping conditions note added |
| Adv7 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Circular reference prevention added |
| Adv8 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Memory exhaustion prevention added |
| Adv9 | High | +5 | FIXED — Graceful sub-task failure handling added |
| Adv10 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — DECOMPOSITION.md update handling added |
| Adv11 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Phase timeout added |
| Adv12 | Medium | +5 | FIXED — Sub-task VRAM limit added to VRAM_CONFIG.md |
| Bug Finder Total | 78 | ||
| Adversarial Bug Finder Total | 65 | ||
| Combined Score | 143 |
Reviewer Comments
(Leave blank for the human reviewer to provide feedback)